Talk:List of quests by story arc

this is a page i am very unhappy with. we kinda decided not to use category pages for site navigation thats ok but this page lacks its focus (this page is put together very poorly, from other pages' copy paste after all right?). i think we need to provide list of flagging guides and xp/favor listing separately. we have Quests by Adventure Pack (sorted by level range) too already. --yoko5000 (Contributions • Message) 01:07, March 17, 2013 (EDT)


 * I agree, this page needs an overhaul... At very least, the sections should be consistent using the same layout. There are some using a four column table, some using and eight column table, some with an unordered list of links, some with a overview/guide and few links...  I'm thinking that a table per arc might look the best. I'm thinking each section/quest should be three rows and eight columns wide.  It should look something like:

border="1"
 * rowspan="3" | Quest Name
 * rowspan="2" | Quest Level
 * rowspan="2" | Total Favor
 * rowspan="2" | Patron
 * Casual XP
 * Normal XP
 * Hard XP
 * Elite XP
 * E-Casual XP
 * E-Normal XP
 * E-Hard XP
 * E-Elite XP
 * colspan="7" | Description and other details/notes
 * E-Elite XP
 * colspan="7" | Description and other details/notes
 * colspan="7" | Description and other details/notes

An alternative, perhaps more efficient is to put the description section on top like:

border="1"
 * rowspan="3" | Quest Name
 * colspan="7" | Description and other details/notes
 * rowspan="2" | Quest Level
 * rowspan="2" | Total Favor
 * rowspan="2" | Patron
 * Casual XP
 * Normal XP
 * Hard XP
 * Elite XP
 * E-Casual XP
 * E-Normal XP
 * E-Hard XP
 * E-Elite XP
 * E-Normal XP
 * E-Hard XP
 * E-Elite XP

Perhaps even this would look better:

border="1"
 * rowspan="2" | Quest Name
 * colspan="5" | Description and other details/notes
 * Quest Level
 * Casual XP
 * Normal XP
 * Hard XP
 * Elite XP
 * Patron
 * Total Favor
 * E-Casual XP
 * E-Normal XP
 * E-Hard XP
 * E-Elite XP
 * E-Normal XP
 * E-Hard XP
 * E-Elite XP

What do you guys think? Give me some ideas and suggestions. ShoeMaker (Contributions • ) 12:30, March 17, 2013 (EDT)

Suggest merging page
This page is inconsistent in the information it provides for each story arc; contains at least one duplicate section; and is otherwise in need of clean-up. Could the same service be provided by merging information about story arcs into Quests by Adventure Pack (sorted by level range)? I'm thinking something like:

The Sharn Syndicate
Story arc.

Ruins of Gianthold
Story arc: The Prison of the Planes, Madstone Crater, The Crucible, Gianthold Tor, The Reaver's Fate. (R) = 12-person raid quest.

Another home should be found for walkthrough information on the page.

If no one objects within a week, I will take that as authorization to give it a try. Hoopy Frood (Contributions • Message) 11:57, July 26, 2015 (EDT)
 * You should probably not think that a week is enough time for everyone to have seen and had time to comment on such a small wiki. Anyways, I currently oppose until there is a way to have the multiple different views available on one page. I know a couple people are whizzes with DPL, and that may be an option or alternatively it could be done with a .js gadget/userscript. You'll have to find someone willing with time to do that or learn to do it yourself and get the working product approved (because an admin would need to put it in MediaWiki space in the case of such a script or a DPL template would need to be fully protected). ShoeMaker (Contributions • Message) 12:15, July 26, 2015 (EDT)
 * I'm also pretty dissatisfied with the way some of the quest list pages are currently presented. They seem to be a mix of automatically populated via categories (not displayed nicely, in my opinion, and missing information that would be nice to have for someone who doesn't know the game backwards, like zone, favour/patron, etc) or manually updated (which in practice means not updated). I think it would be more useful to have everything on a single page, with all relevant details in separate columns, like in a database. Adventure name, pack, favour, pack total favour, etc. Then people can sort by whatever they like. It would be nice if it could be automatically populated like we have with . --Thalone 20:57, July 26, 2015 (EDT)
 * AKA DPL. Still need someone fluent with time to work on it. ShoeMaker (Contributions • Message) 21:22, July 26, 2015 (EDT)
 * I wouldn't say that I'm fluent in it, but I can take a took into redoing the quest list pages with it. Some revisions to Quest might be needed. &mdash;&thinsp; Zav &thinsp; (T·E·C) 22:30, July 26, 2015 (EDT)
 * Quest is probably good but I'm sure QTL will need some work. Let me know. ShoeMaker (Contributions • Message) 23:13, July 26, 2015 (EDT)